In the same way my barely legible schoolboy script has deteriorated over 25 years of digital document creation, my natural urge to halt and record progress in a game diminished. The culprit is the advent of automatic saving, checkpoints, console quick-resume features, and games with such high stakes that I can’t help but save constantly in case things blow up. But I’m not perfect. Laziness creeps in. And this week, I was taught an important lesson deep into a session of the fresh Switch version of Pokémon FireRed on Nintendo's console: you must still manually hit save.
Many years had gone by since I engaged with a classic Pokémon title — never experiencing the Game Boy Advance, the Generation II titles may have been the last mainline Poké-title I played. Consequently, I was thrilled to pony up $19.99 for a trip down memory lane back to Kanto, and an attempt gathering those first 151 pocket monsters. I was instantly transported to the glory days. Over a few successive evenings, I was catching bugs, found a Pikachu in Viridian Forest, knocked out Brock with ease, invested in the useless fish from a shady character, and traversed Mt. Moon carefree and confident.
The critical error: I failed to save even once! And it never crossed my mind.
That Jigglypuff shall never form a bond with that Mankey.
The catastrophe occurred on a night where I didn’t play FireRed… and as my daughter grabbed the Switch for a quick half-hour of the latest game instead, quitting my application in the process. As we all know (a fact I foolishly ignored…) opening a new game on the console will close the active game. Your data is only preserved if the game autosaved or you saved manually prior to changing games. My mistake.
The Progression of Game Saves: From Deliberate to Seamless
It's fair to consider automatic saving, now so seamless most players barely notice it, as a true “next-generation” advancement. Whereas the early computer game Zork had one of the earliest ways to preserve progress, the 1986 Zelda title is widely hailed as a milestone moment for alleviating the sensation of being utterly defeated after a game over because of persistent memory saves in NES games. Naturally, the responsibility remained to save. (And following a single mistake), it was a mistake made only once. In that decade, external memory cards including the original PlayStation made saving more common yet still fragile; failing to save (or misplacing a memory card) could wipe hours of progress. Games like Resident Evil even turned saving into a limited resource.
Today's automatic saving, the one that subdued my natural saving reflex my FireRed run so completely, took hold around the turn of the millennium. Halo: Combat Evolved had its automatic checkpoints as the Call of Duty series honed the approach to streamline challenge and reduce tedious replay. As game worlds expanded — and increasingly non-linear — devs cracked the code on constant background saves and, eventually, the holy grail of suspend/resume.
A Franchise's Adaptation: From Deliberate Action to Automatic Assurance
Curiously, the world of Pokémon is a great reflection of that historical progression. For years, preserving your Pokédex progress was a deliberate choice: fans were taught to select the Save option prior to shutting off their Game Boy or DS. The shift began with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, Game Freak implemented an autosave feature (at first as a toggleable option), marking a major design shift for a franchise known as most tradition-bound franchises.
I can admit failure: A long tenure with Breath of the Wild and modern Mario games completely dulled my saving discipline. I still know better under specific circumstances — I wouldn't dare risk bailing mid-run in something like Hades 2 despite being aware it autosaves after chambers — but be it because my extended absence from older game design, or I’ve just been spoiled, the thought never entered my mind to manually save before redocking. Seven-year-old me would have been more diligent so catastrophically.
The Aftermath: A Discouraged Player
I have not picked up FireRed since my save debacle. When I saw the title screen again to see I had only my starter Squirtle, I felt completely drained. My personal status: Burned.
I might give it another shot… or maybe I’ll stick with the hundreds of new games available now that operate under the assumption I need my hand held. However, my love for retro gaming persists. During times I can distract my child to take a break from her current favorite, we enjoy playing together a collection of classic Bomberman games. Those early SNES games had no save system at all in favor of old-school passwords. Therefore, if I blow myself up, the setback is minimal. That, at least, is reassuring.